* Extreme liner
* Liquid liner
* Pencil liner
* Gel liner
First up - Extreme felt liner:
* £2.00
* Extremely pigmented
* Easy to use
* Doesn't smudge
* Lasts all day
Liquid liner:
* £1.00
* Extremely pigmented
* Great consistency, not too runny
* Plastic tip applicator
* Doesn't smudge
* Lasts all day
* Easy to use
Pencil liner:
* £1.00
* Extremely pigmented
* Very smooth
* Does smudge
* Very smooth
* Does smudge
* Doesn't last on the waterline without dropping
* Great for a smoky eye
* Great as a base
* Sharpener in the lid
And lastly - Gel liner:
* £3.00
* Smooth application
* Doesn't smudge
* Extremely pigmented
* Doesn't smudge
* Extremely pigmented
* Lasts all day
* Comes with a brush in the lid
* Comes with a brush in the lid
It's pretty hard for me to compare the felt, liquid and gel liners because they all do the same (amazing) job. They're pigmented, stay on all day and don't smudge. I go through fazes of which I prefer, when I first bought the liquid liner that's all I used and the same for the gel. When I first used the extreme felt liner, I didn't know if I liked it. It wasn't anything to do with the actual product, I just found felt liners (in general) a bit weird and hard to use. However, that's the one I reach for every day now and I love it.
The pencil liner is probably my least favourite, only because on the rare occasion I do wear pencil liners I like waterproof. This is, however, great for smoky eyes and as a base colour. And for £1.00 who can complain?!
WINNER - So hard to choose but (for now) The extreme felt liner
* Liquid liner review - http://stacey-ajourneyofathousandmiles.blogspot.co.uk/2011/11/review-mua-liquid-eyeliner-black.html
* Gel liner review - http://stacey-ajourneyofathousandmiles.blogspot.co.uk/2012/07/review-mua-gel-eyeliner-in-underground.html
Which is your favourite?
Thanks for reading :)
S xx
Great comparisions, gotta love MUA.... i never liked felt tipped liners bc they dry out so easily. I have my eye on tht bright blue gel liner... It looks amazing.
ReplyDeleteThank you :) This one has lasted surprisingly well, think it's starting to dry out a little now. That blue looks so pretty!
ReplyDeleteS xx